Rate The Sig Above You

remember to put a few words as to why you scored it as you did

^^ 7/10

nice foreground and background and the text works well. foreground seems to stand out too much from background. maybe apply another layer of rain over the top of it to blend it all together

 

9 / 10

Given space constraints etc, they dont get a great deal better.

 

4/10 The background color don't match the forum color, the shadow should have been to the left since the light is coming from the right and since the shadow and her stockings is almost black I would have liked either a different border color, or have the border bordered, that's what brought the rating down, but I do like the smudgy background with the circles. Just noticed that it is leaning just a few degrees too, that gives it a nice touch, that gave it an extra point.

 

I can't see a sig so i'll rate the one above that. 8/10 Superb work. Very classy and excellent composition. I love the subject and colour scheme not to mention the almost painted effect.

 

7/10 awesome sig very tight and kept simple, i only think i miss a text and a bright border

 

Not wishing to spam, but I presume one only posts in here once?

 

You can post when you want to get opinions and ratings from other people. You must also rate the sig above you!

 

I did that, but it seems that you can only post once really until you change your sig - anyways.....no issue

 

Thanks for the constructive criticism

 

Let's see.
I really like the concept of the light centering the 3d effect on the text. Unfortunately, it's backwards. Shouldnt the extrusion go AWAY from your centered light source? You have your light centered on on the "U" center which is fine, but it puts your shadow on the "3" and the lighting on the girl backwards as well as the extrusions on the "INNNDO"
See what I mean? Since you've gone to the effort to use light as your tie together, it's not possible to be the way you have it.

Suggestion.

Move your light source focus to the "D".
1 it makes the light on the text shine on the girl and the 3 tieing the whole piece together in a possible way.
2 the "D" looks like a light and the "O" can be flipped without hassle to show the light is from the "D" easily. +, using the "D" as your light center means you can use the girl, 3,3rd "N" without any work.
3 By using "D" as light source, you can have the "I" even darker, which with no background will draw attention to the name without overwhelming the girl & 3. (I wouldnt make it too dark, you want to have the extrusion on the outside even noticeably darker.)

I'm posting my current sig

so that any commentary will make sense in the future.

 

5/10

light bulbs. pfft!

 

0/10 No sig at all!? WTF Eve!?

 

9/10. nice doggy!

 

10/10

Can't fucking find a fault in this one, the dimensions on the text are perfect and it's beyond me how you got the girls shadow to look so natural on the text. She's placed at a perfect angle as well, fucking brilliant Lukin!

 

9/10..
i like the dog, the background fits perfect colourwise..
letters look good too. perhaps a liiittle bit too "sterile"..

all in all a great sig

 

6/10

Oddly enough I like how the text frames the small little thing, I think it could be more creative in the text department, but it definitely does the job as is!

 

never been a fan of the sig restrictions here. I wish there was more height than width.

 

i think it sucks that if you wanna show the celebs body, they need to be in a lying position ^^

 

Remember to rate the sig above you peeps

5/10

 

no comment?

8/10.. simple (the outer appearance), but effective.. love her being in front of the border..
is that Liv Tyler?